Restaurant owner sitting alone at a table in her empty dining room after closing, a calculator and notebook in front of her

Toast vs Square vs Clover Capital: POS Loans Compared

October 27, 2026•11 min read
Growth Capital
Toast vs Square vs Clover Capital: POS Loans Compared
October 27, 2026  ·  11 min read  ·  Build&Fund Team

Open your POS dashboard on a slow Tuesday and there it is: a pre-approved offer, one click from your bank account. Run Toast, Square, or Clover at the counter and DoorDash by the pass, and you may have two. You searched "square capital vs toast capital" because you want to know which costs less before you click.

Here is the honest answer. None of the four publishes a rate card, so nobody can rank Toast, Square, Clover, and DoorDash Capital by brand. Two publish an example: Toast, a $10,000 loan with a $1,200 fee; Square, a $10,000 loan with a $1,300 fee. All four run on one machine: a fee set when you accept, repaid out of a share of the sales you already ring. The cheapest is set by two numbers on your own offer: the fee, and how fast your sales pay it back. By our math, Square's bigger fee repaid over 12 months costs about half as much per year as Toast's smaller fee repaid over 6.

Credit where it is due: no application packet, payments that flex with sales, money in days. Below: how each works, the yearly cost math, the fine print, a side-by-side table, and a 10-minute way to find the cheapest offer on your screen.

How Toast, Square, Clover, and DoorDash Capital work

Every POS lender sees what you sell before you ask. That data is the underwriting. Accept and a fixed share of your sales goes back until the amount plus the fee is paid.

Toast Capital

A real loan, issued by WebBank. Standard offers run from $1,000 to $300,000, and introductory offers from $5,000 to $100,000, per Toast's loan FAQ. Target terms are 90, 270, or 360 days. The holdback comes out of daily card sales processed through Toast, "including any tips, taxes, service charges." No personal guarantee. We took it apart line by line in our Toast Capital review.

Square Loans

Also a real loan, underwritten and issued by Square Financial Services, a Utah-chartered industrial bank. Offers run up to $500,000, per Square's loans page. The repayment rate applies to gross card sales, "including tips and taxes paid by your customers." Two things set it apart: minimum payments, listed on your offer, and a personal guarantee on loans over $250,000.

Clover Capital

Not a loan. In the words of Fiserv, which owns Clover: "Clover Capital is not a loan." Merchants pay the advance back with a percentage of their daily sales, with no fixed term and no personal guarantee, per Fiserv's Clover Capital as a Service sheet from March 2025. Clover publishes no fee example and no holdback range.

DoorDash Capital

A merchant cash advance, provided by Parafin, not by DoorDash. DoorDash's own page says these advances "are not extensions of credit or loans." Payments are a percentage of your DoorDash sales, matched to your payout schedule, so delivery orders set the pace, not your dining room. One fixed fee, no interest, no credit check, no personal guarantee, and no payment in a period with no sales.

What all four get right
  • No compounding interest. Toast, Square, and DoorDash charge one fixed fee; Clover sets its fee on your offer.
  • Repayment flexes with sales: a slow day means a smaller payment.
  • Fast money: as soon as the next business day at Toast and Square, 1 to 2 business days at DoorDash, 2 to 3 at Clover.
  • No personal guarantee at Toast, Clover, or DoorDash, and none at Square up to $250,000.
Source: Toast Capital Loan FAQ, Square Loans page, Fiserv Clover Capital as a Service sheet, DoorDash Capital page

What a fixed fee really costs per year

A fixed fee feels safe because the dollars never change. Repay Square's example loan in 3 months or in 12 and you still owe $1,300. But time changes what those dollars cost. Repay over 12 months and you rented $10,000 for a year. Repay over 3 and you paid the same $1,300 for a quarter. By our calculation, that is about 25% a year on the slow path and about 99% on the fast one. Toast's New York disclosure FAQ agrees: on a fixed fee, "the APR will increase with a shorter repayment period."

Estimated APR of a $1,300 fee on $10,000 25% 50% 75% 100% 3 months: 99% 99% 3 months 6 months: 50% 50% 6 months 9 months: 33% 33% 9 months 12 months: 25% 25% 12 months
Source: Square's $10,000 loan example with a $1,300 fixed fee (Square Support Center, Repay your loan). Build&Fund calculation of estimated APR by repayment time, equal daily repayments, 365-day year.

Now put the two published examples on the same footing. Toast's $1,200 fee repaid over 6 months works out to about 46% a year. Square's $1,300 fee repaid over 12 months works out to about 25%. The bigger fee is the cheaper money. Rank POS loans by brand or by fee alone and you get the wrong answer.

Two caveats. Toast says longer loans generally carry larger fixed fees. And the yearly rate is a yardstick, not a bill: you never pay more than the fixed fee. Your sales set the speed, and the speed sets the yearly cost. In New York, the Commercial Finance Disclosure Law covers sales-based financing up to $2.5 million and spells out how providers must calculate the APR they disclose, per the New York Department of Financial Services.

Key Insight
The fee is not the price. The fee divided by the time you keep the money is the price. A $1,300 fee you keep for a year can cost less than a $1,200 fee you keep for six months.
Line cook and expediter at a busy restaurant pass during a Saturday dinner rush, plates going out to a server
A packed Saturday repays a POS loan faster, which is exactly what pushes a fixed fee's yearly cost up.

The fine print that separates them

  1. 1
    Minimum payments
    Toast's 90-day loans have no minimum payments. Its 270-day and 360-day loans can carry a Repayment Milestone Schedule: every 30 days, payments to date must reach a disclosed minimum, or the gap may be collected by ACH. Square has minimum payments; miss one and Square can debit the shortfall from your Square balance or bank account, and your repayment rate may increase. DoorDash says no sales in a period means no payment. Clover advertises no fixed term.
  2. 2
    A hard stop
    Toast's maximum term is 60 days past the target term. Square's maturity date sits in the summary box of your loan agreement, and a balance left then can be debited from your account. Find that date before you sign.
  3. 3
    Guarantees and liens
    Square requires a personal guarantee on loans over $250,000 and, above $100,000, may take a security interest in your business assets and file a UCC statement. Toast reserves the right to file a UCC lien. DoorDash and Fiserv say no personal guarantee.
  4. 4
    Lock-in
    Toast will not let you sign for a Toast Capital Loan while a merchant cash advance is outstanding, and DoorDash and Clover both describe their products as advances, not loans. Ask Toast before you stack them. The offer screen is also a sales channel: Fiserv's sheet tells software partners they can qualify for revenue sharing by promoting Clover Capital. Carrying an advance now? Start with the six realistic ways out of an MCA.
  5. 5
    No reward for paying early
    Pay off Toast, Square, or DoorDash Capital early and you still owe the full fee. Each says the fee is fixed when you accept.
Every POS loan is paid back out of sales your restaurant already made. No offer screen puts that part in bold.

Toast vs Square vs Clover vs DoorDash Capital, side by side

The one structure that works differently sits in the last row.

OptionHow you repayWhat it costsPaid from
Toast CapitalFixed % of daily card sales run through ToastOne fixed fee. Toast's example, $1,200 on $10,000: about 46% a year over 6 months, 23% over 12Card sales you already earned, tips and taxes included
Square LoansFixed % of daily card sales, plus minimum paymentsOne fixed fee. Square's example, $1,300 on $10,000: about 50% a year over 6 months, 25% over 12Card sales you already earned, tips and taxes included
Clover CapitalA percentage of daily sales, no fixed termA fee set on your offer. Clover publishes no exampleSales you already earned
DoorDash CapitalFixed % of DoorDash sales, on your payout scheduleOne fixed fee. DoorDash publishes no exampleDelivery sales you already earned
Capital + CustomersOnly as new diners come in and redeem food and beverage creditNo interest, no factor rateNew guests, never a daily card pull
Sources: Toast Capital Loan FAQ and New York disclosure FAQ, Square Support Center and Square Loans page, Fiserv Clover Capital as a Service sheet (March 2025), DoorDash Capital page. Yearly figures are Build&Fund calculations assuming equal daily repayment.

On cost, Toast and Square land close on their published examples; Clover and DoorDash publish nothing to compare. On structure, DoorDash is the odd one out: its payments are based only on DoorDash sales. Square is the strictest on paper, with minimums and a personal guarantee above $250,000. Notice what every row but one has in common: each is repaid out of sales your restaurant already made.

See where your restaurant lands.
60-second check. No credit check, no personal guarantee.
See If Your Restaurant Qualifies

How to find the cheapest offer on your screen

You need three things: the amount, the fee, and an honest guess at how long your sales will take to repay it.

The 10-minute comparison
  • Payoff days: amount plus fee, divided by what the holdback collects on a typical day (holdback rate times daily sales on that platform). For Toast and Square, use gross card volume, tips and taxes included.
  • Yearly cost, our rule of thumb: double the fee as a percent of the amount, multiply by 12, divide by months to repay. Square's example over 12 months: 13% doubled is about 26%, close to our exact 25%.
  • Ask for the estimated APR in writing, then check minimums, maturity, and any guarantee or lien before you accept.

A POS loan makes sense when the money pays for itself inside the term: a walk-in cooler that died on a Friday, inventory for a busy season you can count on. Skip it if you are covering a loss or rolling one advance into the next. Compare every option in our guide to funding for restaurants, and if the bank already said no, read why banks won't lend to restaurants and our list of merchant cash advance alternatives.

Restaurant host welcoming a group of new guests through the front door of a busy bistro in the evening
New diners are the engine of Capital + Customers. You repay only as they come in and redeem, never from the sales you already ring.

The other way to fund growth: repay with new diners, not your sales

Build&Fund backs great restaurant operators with new customers through their doors and the capital to handle them. Through our capital partners, qualifying restaurants get access to $10,000 to $50,000+ in initial funding, in exchange for future food and beverage credit. You repay only as new diners come in and redeem that credit. Not a percentage of the sales you already ring. Not a daily card pull. Never a cash payment.

One document starts your review: your POS sales report. Decisions move fast, and approved operators are funded within days. For qualifying operators, second rounds can quickly scale to six figures. No credit check. No personal guarantee.

Who qualifies: $500K+ in annual sales and a 4.0+ Google rating. Every food and beverage establishment can qualify: full service, quick service, bars, and cafes.

From application to funded
  1. 1
    Confirm you clear the bar
    $500K+ in annual sales and a 4.0+ Google rating.
  2. 2
    Submit one document
    Your POS sales report. No credit check, no personal guarantee.
  3. 3
    Fast decision
    Decisions move fast. No weeks of back-and-forth.
  4. 4
    Funded within days
    $10,000 to $50,000+ to start, through our capital partners.
  5. 5
    Repay only as new diners redeem credit
    Food and beverage credit, never in cash.
  6. 6
    Scale as it proves out
    For qualifying operators, second rounds can quickly scale to six figures.
You back your regulars every night. Let us back you.
Funding through our capital partners, repaid only as new diners come in and redeem, never skimmed off the sales you already ring. See if your restaurant qualifies to be backed.
Apply to Get Backed
60-second check. No credit check, no personal guarantee.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Square Capital cheaper than Toast Capital?
It depends on your offer, because neither publishes a rate card. Square's help center uses a $10,000 loan with a $1,300 fixed fee as an example, and Toast's New York disclosure FAQ uses a $10,000 loan with a $1,200 fee. By our calculation, Toast's example costs about 46% a year if repaid in 6 months, while Square's costs about 25% a year if repaid in 12.
What percentage does Clover Capital take?
Clover does not publish a holdback range. Fiserv, which owns Clover, says merchants pay back the advance with a percentage of their daily sales, with no fixed term and no personal guarantee. The exact percentage appears on your offer.
How does DoorDash Capital work?
DoorDash Capital is a merchant cash advance provided by Parafin, not by DoorDash. You repay the lump sum plus one fixed fee as a percentage of your DoorDash sales. There is no credit check and no personal guarantee, and approved funds typically arrive in 1 to 2 business days.
Do POS loans require a personal guarantee?
Mostly no. Toast, DoorDash, and Fiserv for Clover all say no personal guarantee is required. Square requires one on loans over $250,000.
Is a POS loan the same as a merchant cash advance?
Not always. Toast Capital loans are issued by WebBank and Square Loans by Square Financial Services, so both are loans. Clover Capital and DoorDash Capital are advances, which their providers say are not loans.
Is there restaurant funding that is not repaid from card sales?
Yes. Through our capital partners, Build&Fund backs qualifying restaurants with $10,000 to $50,000+ in initial funding in exchange for future food and beverage credit, repaid only as new diners come in and redeem it. It is not a daily card pull and never a cash payment. There is no credit check and no personal guarantee. You qualify with $500K+ in annual sales and a 4.0+ Google rating.
Build&Fund
Build&Fund Team
Accountants are historians. We are hunters. Build&Fund finds the money hiding in your restaurant, bar, or club.
Build&Fund helps restaurant, bar, and hospitality operators recover and grow capital. This article is educational content, not financial advice. Costs, fees, and terms vary by provider and by your restaurant's numbers. Confirm any figure with the provider and a qualified financial professional before you sign. Toast, Toast Capital, Square, Square Loans, Clover, Clover Capital, Fiserv, DoorDash, DoorDash Capital, Parafin, WebBank are trademarks of their respective owners. Build&Fund is not affiliated with them.
Build&Fund Advisory Team

Build&Fund Advisory Team

Build&Fund Content Team

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Back to Blog