You typed "how to get more customers to my restaurant" after close, with the bank app open in another tab. Most answers rank ideas by how fun they sound. This one ranks 11 plays by what a new guest actually costs you.
The short answer: the cheapest new guests come from things you control. A complete Google listing, honest reviews, your own guest list and gift cards cost hours, not cash. Next come plays you pay for in food or a small fee, like credit for regulars who bring a friend. Last come deal vouchers, paid ads and delivery apps, which need cash up front or charge on every order. All 11 can work. Over a year, they do not cost the same.
It matters now. In September, 44% of operators told the National Restaurant Association their traffic fell from a year earlier, against 42% who saw it rise. It was the 19th time in 20 months that more operators lost traffic than gained it.
How we ranked the 11 plays
One number: what a new guest costs over their first year, not their first night. The base formula is Toast's: marketing expenses divided by total new customers, with "the amount you discount for a promotion" counted as an expense. Our customer acquisition cost guide walks through that math.
Then one question most lists skip: do you pay again on visit two? A guest who found you on Google comes back free. A guest who keeps ordering through an app costs a commission every time.
- Cash and margin both count. A $10 discount is a $10 cost.
- Year one, not night one: an illustrative guest who visits six times on a $40 check.
Plays 1 to 4: free, but they cost you hours
1. Finish your Google Business Profile
Google is blunt: "There's no way to request or pay for a better local ranking on Google." It also says businesses with complete and accurate info are more likely to show up in local search results. Fill in every field, add holiday hours, and post real photos of the room and the plates.
2. Ask every guest for a review, then answer them all
Per the same Google page, "More reviews and positive ratings can help your business's local ranking." Google lets you ask with a link or a QR code, so put it on the receipt. Reply briefly, without pitching deals, as Google advises. One hard line: never pay or discount for a review. See the fine print below.
3. Bring back the guests you already won
The cheapest extra cover is a second visit. Capture an email or phone number on visit one: the reservation, the online order, the loyalty sign-up. Then give them a reason to return. A guest who comes back through your own list costs you the software, not a commission.
4. Sell gift cards to the regulars who love you
A gift card from a regular puts a new guest in your seat with the meal already paid for. You hold the cash first and serve the food later. Our holiday gift card strategy shows how to run them, and the federal expiration rule is in the fine print below.
Plays 5 to 8: you pay in food or a small fee
5. Pay regulars to bring a friend, in food
Give the regular $10 off their next visit and the friend $10 off their first. At face value, that is $20 for one new guest. In cash it is less. The National Restaurant Association puts the median full-service food and non-alcohol beverage cost at 32.0% of sales for 2024, so $20 of credit costs about $6.40 in food (Build&Fund calculation, illustrative).
6. Partner with the businesses next door
Hotel front desks, office managers, gyms and theaters all get asked where to eat. Feed their staff once, leave cards with a first-visit code, and count the codes. The cost is a tasting plate and an hour.
7. Give people a night worth showing up for
A standing trivia night, a winemaker dinner, an industry night. Events give strangers a reason to try you. Our guide to filling empty tables on weeknights has six more plays like this.
8. List your tables where diners already book
Per OpenTable's published US pricing, Core is $299 a month plus $1 per network cover, with bookings from your own website included. Basic is $149 a month, with network covers free for 30 days and $1.50 each after. You pay only for seated diners. The catch: a guest who rebooks through the network every time costs you every time. Six network visits on Core is $6. Per guest, that is the cheapest paid play here; the monthly plan is why it ranks eighth.
Plays 9 to 11: you pay in margin, or in cash up front
9. Deal vouchers
Groupon charges no upfront fees and takes a commission on each redeemed voucher at a rate agreed before launch. It says there is no universal rate; its examples run 20% to 40%. On a half-off $40 meal at 20%, the guest pays $20, Groupon keeps $4, and you collect $16. That visit costs you $24, or $28 at 40% (Build&Fund calculation, illustrative). More in our Groupon review.
10. Paid social and search ads
Ads are fast and targeted, but you pay before anyone walks in. In Toast's worked example, $1,000 in Facebook ads plus $40 in discounts wins 20 new customers: $52 each. Yours will differ. Whether visit two is free depends on play 3.
11. Delivery apps
DoorDash lists no monthly fee, no contract, and delivery commissions of 15% on Basic, 25% on Plus and 30% on Premier. Nothing is due until an order lands, which is real value. But the commission never stops. At 25% on a $40 order, every order costs $10, first or sixth. Six orders in a year is $60 (Build&Fund calculation, illustrative). Pickup is 6% on every plan, so steer app regulars there.
The fine print that matters
-
1Never trade anything for a reviewGoogle's policy bars incentives such as "payment, discounts, free goods and/or services" for reviews, and bars selectively asking only happy guests. The FTC's fake review rule, announced August 14, 2024, bans incentives conditioned on a review's sentiment and lets the agency seek civil penalties against knowing violators.
-
2Get permission before you textThe FCC treats a text as a call under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act, and its November 2023 fact sheet says texters need prior express invitation or permission before sending a marketing text. Collect it in writing at sign-up.
-
3Every marketing email needs an exitPer the FTC's CAN-SPAM compliance guide, commercial email needs an opt-out, your physical postal address, and an honest subject line. Opt-outs must be honored within 10 business days, and each violating email can draw penalties of up to $53,088.
-
4Gift card money cannot expire for five yearsUnder the federal gift card rule, 12 CFR 1005.20, funds cannot expire sooner than five years after the card was issued or last loaded.
The main plays head to head
| Option | How you pay for the guest | What it costs | Paid from |
|---|---|---|---|
| Google, reviews, your own list | Your time | No cash; local ranking cannot be bought | Hours |
| Referral credit | Food credit for regular and friend | $20 at face, about $6.40 in food | Margin on two checks |
| Reservation network (OpenTable Core) | Monthly plan plus fee per seated network cover | $299 a month plus $1 per cover | Monthly cash |
| Deal voucher (Groupon) | Discount plus commission on redemption | $24 on a half-off $40 meal at 20% | The check, before payout |
| Paid social ads | Ad spend before anyone walks in | $52 per new customer in Toast's example | Cash, up front |
| Delivery app (DoorDash Plus) | Commission on every delivery order | $10 on every $40 order at 25% | Your payout, every order |
| Capital + Customers | Only as new diners come in and redeem food and beverage credit | No interest, no factor rate | New guests, never a daily card pull |
Every row but the last buys a guest with time, food, fees or cash. The last row is funding, not marketing: through our capital partners, in exchange for future food and beverage credit. You repay only as new diners come in and redeem that credit, not a percentage of the sales you already ring.
When paying for a new guest is the right call
- You have done plays 1 to 4 first.
- You capture the guest on visit one, so visit two costs nothing.
- Your kitchen can take more covers without an unplanned shift.
- You know what a visit leaves you. At the 32.0% median food cost, food takes about $12.80 of a $40 check (Build&Fund calculation).
- You measure it: one channel, one code, 30 days.
Skip it when the real problem is cash, not traffic. Start with our guides to restaurant working capital and slow season cash flow. And protect your Google rating. It feeds your local ranking, and it is one of the two things that qualify you for Capital + Customers: $500K+ in annual sales and a 4.0+ Google rating.
The other way to fund growth: repay with new diners, not your sales
Build&Fund backs great restaurant operators with new customers through their doors and the capital to handle them. Through our capital partners, qualifying restaurants get access to $10,000 to $50,000+ in initial funding, in exchange for future food and beverage credit. You repay only as new diners come in and redeem that credit. Not a percentage of the sales you already ring. Not a daily card pull. Never a cash payment.
One document starts your review: your POS sales report. Decisions move fast, and approved operators are funded within days. For qualifying operators, second rounds can quickly scale to six figures. No credit check. No personal guarantee.
Who qualifies: $500K+ in annual sales and a 4.0+ Google rating. Every food and beverage establishment can qualify: full service, quick service, bars, and cafes.
-
1Confirm you clear the bar$500K+ in annual sales and a 4.0+ Google rating.
-
2Submit one documentYour POS sales report. No credit check, no personal guarantee.
-
3Fast decisionDecisions move fast. No weeks of back-and-forth.
-
4Funded within days$10,000 to $50,000+ to start, through our capital partners.
-
5Repay only as new diners redeem creditFood and beverage credit, never in cash.
-
6Scale as it proves outFor qualifying operators, second rounds can quickly scale to six figures.
Frequently Asked Questions

